| James D. Foley, S.J. | 1893 - 1897 |
| Michael F. Dowling, S.J. | 1897 - 1898 |
| James A. Dowling, S.J. | 1898 - 1899 |
| Thomas S. Fitzgerald, S.J. | 1899 - 1911 |
| James A. McCarthy, S.J. | 1911 - 1913 |
| James D. Foley, S.J. | 1913 - 1920 |
| Louis Kellinger, S.J. | 1920 - 1922 |
| Terence H. Devlin, S.J. | 1922 - 1927 |
| Joseph Milet, S.J. | 1927 - 1931 |
| Michael L. Palmer, S.J. | 1931 - 1934 |
| Patrcik A. Mullens, S.J. | 1934 - 1941 |
| Richard A. Cahill, S.J. | 1941 - 1963 |
| James Corrigan, S.J. | 1963 - 1968 |
| John J. Halloran, S.J. | 1968 - 1974 |
| Robert Purcell, S.J. | 1974 - 1984 |
| Doug Leonhardt, S.J. | 1984 - 1988 |
| Andrew Alexander, S.J. | 1988 - 1996 |
| George Winzenburg, S.J. | 1996 - 2002 |
| Peter J. Etzel, S.J. | 2002 - 2009 |
| Karl J. Voelker, S.J. | 2009 - 2013 |
| D. Edward Mathie, S.J. | 2013 - 2014 |
| John P. Schlegel, S.J. | 2014 - 2015 |
| James P. Flaherty, S.J. | 2015 - 2022 |
| R. Benjamin Osborne, S.J. | 2022 - 2024 |
| Michael R. Simone, S.J. | 2024- |